The proposal of the president of Mexico, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, to form a new Latin American integration project with an entity that replaces the Organization of American States (OAS) generated reactions throughout the continent.
According to some opinions, the proposal of the Mexican president seeks to politically strengthen the already founded Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC), in order to counteract the hegemonic influence of the United States over Latin America.
“The proposal is, neither more nor less, than to build something similar to the European Union, but attached to our history, our reality and our identities. In that spirit, the replacement of the OAS by a truly autonomous body should not be ruled out, not nobody’s lackey, but rather a mediator at the request and acceptance of the parties in conflict, in matters of human rights and democracy, “said López Obrador in a speech delivered on Saturday, July 24, during a ceremony commemorating the birth of Liberator Simón Bolívar, prior to a CELAC meeting in Mexico City.
The statement came after months of confrontation between Mexican diplomacy and Luis Almagro, Secretary General of the OAS, who has been pointed out by Latin American leaders of operate in the interests of the United States. in the region.
Although López Obrador did not explicitly mention CELAC, the speech was delivered on the occasion of the organization’s meeting held in Mexico, in the presence of diplomats who attended the meeting.
On the other hand, the Mexican president considered that the new proposed integration body should include the United States and Canada, but based on the recognition of the sovereignty of nations, instead of the attempts at coercion that have historically prevailed. Something that, according to López Obrador, would be convenient for Washington given China’s economic growth.
“It would be a grave mistake to kick Samson, but at the same time we have strong reasons to enforce our sovereignty and demonstrate with arguments, without slogans, that we are not a protectorate, a colony or its backyard, “said the Mexican president.
Furthermore, he said, “China’s outsized growth has strengthened the view in the US that we should be viewed as allies and not like distant neighbors“.
Bolivian President Luis Arce backed his Mexican counterpart’s proposal.
“We echo the words of the brother, López Obrador, in the idea of replace the OAS with another body truly autonomous, that expresses regional balances, respects the self-determination of the peoples and does not allow for the hegemony of a single State, “Arce wrote.
We echo the brother’s words, @lopezobrador_, in the idea of replacing the @OAS_official by another truly autonomous body, which expresses regional balances, respects the self-determination of the peoples and does not allow for the hegemony of a single State. pic.twitter.com/lzLrm0msaM
– Luis Alberto Arce Catacora (Lucho Arce) (@LuchoXBolivia) July 25, 2021
For his part, the president of Venezuela, Nicolás Maduro, joined the Mexican president’s proposal and proposed strengthening CELAC as a substitute for the OAS.
The speech of Pdte. @lopezobrador_ before the XXI Meeting of Foreign Ministers of CELAC, he was masterful. He brilliantly described the work of the Liberator and placed key themes: the need to consolidate the path of CELAC and retake the original spirit of the organization. pic.twitter.com/xLWsupJ7Nz
– Nicolás Maduro (@NicolasMaduro) July 25, 2021
However, Colombia rejected the proposal, considering that regional integration should seek “closer” relations with the US and Canada, in the words of the Colombian Foreign Minister, Marta Lucía Ramírez.
Although some voices asked to replace the OAS, I defended this organization and proposed its complementarity and convergence with CELAC. I also suggested that extra-regional cooperation should include closer relations with 🇺🇸 and 🇨🇦, as they have been developing with China. pic.twitter.com/uMAbJ1ikvr
– Marta Lucía Ramírez (@mluciaramirez) July 24, 2021
According to some versions published in the Argentine press, Mexico has initiated some political efforts in order for Argentina to assume the presidency of CELAC in 2022, so that Alberto Fernández will take the lead in the counterweight to the OAS.
According to analysts, this process of checks and balances could even be reinforced by the recent electoral victory of the leftist Pedro Castillo in the Peruvian presidential elections, which would serve to pay for the consolidation of CELAC.
The recognition of the triumph of Pedro Castillo is one more step in the fight to consolidate democracy on the Continent. May his presidency not only serve for a just distribution of wealth in Peru but also to recreate institutions such as UNASUR and CELAC.
— Leopoldo Moreau (@MoreauLeopoldo) July 20, 2021
What is CELAC?
CELAC is a body created in 2011, mainly promoted by the late Venezuelan leader Hugo Chávez, and which brings together 33 countries in Latin America and the Caribbean, not including the US and Canada.
To understand its conformation, we must go back to 2005. That year, in Mar del Plata, Argentina, the IV Summit of the Americas was held, but at the same time, the Peoples’ Summit was held, which Chávez attended. . The Venezuelan leader pointed out that the objective of the meeting was to bury the Free Trade Area of the Americas (Alca), promoted by the US and Canada.
Then, he uttered his remembered “Alca, Alca, to hell!” and he also pointed out: “The peoples no longer accept surrender presidents here, or presidents kneeling towards imperialism. The peoples ask for true leaders.”
Later, with the majority of progressive governments in the region, the Union of South American Nations (Unasur) was created, whose Constitutive Treaty was signed in 2008; but it was still pending to unite South America with Central America and the Caribbean.
In December 2008, the Summit of Latin America and the Caribbean on Integration and Development (CALC) was held in Salvador de Bahía, Brazil, initiative of then Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula Da Silva, and it was the first time in 200 years that the representatives of the countries of the region met without the US and Canada. There they promoted regional integration and other meetings.
In February 2010, the Unity Summit was held in Rivera Maya, Cancun, Mexico; and, finally, in December 2011, in Caracas, Venezuela, the founding summit of CELAC was held.
Current geopolitics in the region
In 2020, the administration of Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro decided to temporarily withdraw from CELAC. However, the expectation of a possible triumph of the leftist Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva – who heads the main electoral preference polls in the 2022 Brazilian presidential elections – could give a new impetus to that regional entity.
On the other hand, the forthcoming inauguration of the leftist Pedro Castillo in Peru, together with the presence of Arce in Bolivia, Maduro in Venezuela, Fernández in Argentina and López Obrador in Mexico, configure a scenario prone to promoting this integrating initiative of the region that, If it is resumed, it will have the challenge of negotiating with the most conservative governments, which are reluctant to these initiatives.
In the panorama still decisive actors remain to be defined. In Chile, for example, presidential elections will be held in November 2021 (in the midst of a historic process for the creation of a new Constitution), while Colombia will do the same, in May 2022.
In this way, what happens in the internal politics of countries such as Brazil, Colombia and Chile, between 2021 and 2022, could be a crucial point to give political viability to López Obrador’s proposal, when creating a more multilateral organization. equitable vis-à-vis US interests on the continent.
Likewise, Argentina presented formally his candidacy to preside over CELAC from 2022, once Mexico concludes his term at the head of the organization.
Allies against China?
The experts consulted agree that the threat posed to the US by China’s economic growth, in addition to Mexico’s leadership, are key factors in promoting a new continental integration.
“You can now see how from this government in Mexico a relationship a little more marked with Latin America begins, something that the last neoliberal governments in Mexico put aside in order to integrate subordinately to the United States and North America”, says Aníbal García, researcher at the Latin American Strategic Center for Geopolitics (CELAG).
The specialist believes that a second “wave of progressive governments” in Latin America now allows “other type of integration outside the US in a more autonomous way. “
A situation that is explained, to a large extent, from the crisis of the neoliberal model in Latin America.
“So much has been accumulated to the detriment of the vast majority, that they no longer have the consensus they had before and that is clear in the number of demonstrations that have taken place in various Latin American countries, “he adds.
For his part, the researcher in international relations at the University of Guadalajara, Jesús López Almejo, believes that the OAS was never an American integration project, but rather an instrument to contain communism in the context of the Cold War.
For this reason, the expert considers it positive that the Mexican president has proposed the creation of a new body, which “guides the interests of the different participants towards an integration truly regional“.
However, he warns that constituting a bloc without the US and pretending that Washington cooperates on equal terms is something “difficult” because, in his opinion, part of the success of US policy has consisted “of weaken to different countries to dominate them and put them at your service “.
Manuel Hernandez Borbolla