10 Best Rubbermaid Replacement Lids for 2025: Top Picks and Reviews

If you’ve ever experienced the frustration of mismatched food storage containers and lids, you’re not alone. Finding the best Rubbermaid replacement lids only can be a game-changer for keeping your kitchen organized and reducing waste. In 2025, the demand for replacement lids on Amazon has surged, leading to a myriad of options for consumers. In this article, we will review the top 10 products available on Amazon, ensuring you find the perfect replacement lid to match your needs.

Top 10 Rubbermaid Replacement Lids on Amazon

Rubbermaid 1987026 Replacement Lid

Best for: Versatile Use

The Rubbermaid 1987026 Replacement Lid is designed to fit various Rubbermaid food storage containers, offering incredible versatility. This lid features a durable construction that ensures it will withstand daily use and remain intact over time.

Pros:

• Fits multiple container sizes.
• Microwave and dishwasher safe.
• Durable material resists cracking.

Cons:

• Some customers found it slightly loose on smaller containers.
• Limited color options.

Rubbermaid 2080040 Easy Find Lids

Best for: Easy Storage

The Rubbermaid 2080040 Easy Find Lids come with a unique design that helps in keeping your kitchen organized. The lids snap together for efficient storage, making them a great solution for those short on space.

Pros:

• Lids stack easily for storage.
• BPA-free and safe for food contact.
• Great for various container sizes.

Cons:

• Some users reported a need for a tighter seal.
• Limited availability of different colors.

Rubbermaid 1877395 Replacement Lids for Containers

Best for: Sturdiness

Constructed from high-quality plastic, the Rubbermaid 1877395 Replacement Lids are built to last. Designed specifically for specific Rubbermaid container models, these lids offer a snug fit that ensures your food stays fresh longer.

Pros:

• High durability and longevity.
• Lid fits securely to prevent spills.
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

Cons:

• Primarily designed for specific models only.
• Can be more expensive than generic options.

Rubbermaid Commercial Products 1962805 Replacement Lid

No products found.

Best for: Commercial Use

If you are seeking a lid that can stand up to rigorous daily use, consider the Rubbermaid Commercial Products 1962805. This professional-grade lid is designed specifically for foodservice, providing a secure fit that can withstand the demands of a busy kitchen.

Pros:

• Heavy-duty construction for long-lasting use.
• Designed for commercial-grade containers.
• Great for keeping large quantities of food fresh.

Cons:

• Bulkier than standard lids.
• Pricier compared to residential products.

Rubbermaid 1760264 Easy Find Lid

Best for: Compact Design

The Rubbermaid 1760264 Easy Find Lid offers a compact design that is perfect for space-saving storage. This lid fits various Rubbermaid containers and stacks well, making organization a breeze in any kitchen.

Pros:

• Space-efficient design for storage.
• Versatile fit for multiple containers.
• Microwave safe for reheating.

Cons:

• Some users found it not fit as snugly as they’d like.
• Limited size options.

Rubbermaid Brilliance 1991140 Replacement Lid

Best for: Clarity

With exceptional clarity, the Rubbermaid Brilliance 1991140 Replacement Lid provides a sleek look while keeping food fresh. This lid is perfect for those who appreciate aesthetics along with functionality.

Pros:

• Crystal clear design for visibility.
• Stackable for easy storage.
• BPA-free for food safety.

Cons:

• A little pricier than other models.
• Slightly more fragile compared to other options.

Rubbermaid 1866998 Replacement Lids for Easy Find Containers

No products found.

Best for: Easy Matching

The Rubbermaid 1866998 Replacement Lids feature a color-coded design that takes the guesswork out of matching lids with containers. Ideal for busy households, these lids make organization quick and efficient.

Pros:

• Color-coded for easy matching.
• Dishwasher and microwave safe.
• Stacks easily for better storage.

Cons:

• Lids may wear down over time with frequent use.
• Limited fit for certain container styles.

Rubbermaid Lock-its 1820494 Replacement Lids

Best for: Leak-Proof Storage

If you’re looking for lids that keep things locked in place, consider the Rubbermaid Lock-its 1820494 Replacement Lids. These are designed to provide a leak-proof seal, ideal for liquids and marinades.

Pros:

• Leak-proof design prevents spills.
• BPA-free and safe for food storage.
• Excellent for travel and meal prep.

Cons:

• May not fit all standard Rubbermaid containers.
• Bulkier than standard lids.

Rubbermaid 2188410 Replacement Lids

Best for: Frequent Users

For those who frequently utilize food storage, the Rubbermaid 2188410 Replacement Lids offer a reliable solution. Durable and versatile, these lids cater to an array of container types.

Pros:

• Durable construction for repeated use.
• Versatile for various sizes.
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

Cons:

• May not be suitable for all models.
• Fading can occur with prolonged use.

Rubbermaid TakeAlongs 1901158 Replacement Lids

Best for: On-the-Go Foods

If you are someone who enjoys bringing meals on-the-go, the Rubbermaid TakeAlongs 1901158 Replacement Lids are perfect for you. Designed for travel and portability, these lids offer a secure seal that keeps food fresh.

Pros:

• Perfect for meal prepping and travel.
• Leak-proof design for liquids.
• Lightweight and easy to carry.

Cons:

• Less sturdy than bulkier lids.
• Limited sizes available.

Each of these products offers unique features tailored to meet various needs, but finding the best Rubbermaid replacement lids only for your kitchen should come down to what fits best for your storage and organizational goals. Happy shopping in 2025!

Buying Guide for Rubbermaid Replacement Lids

If you’ve ever lost or damaged the lid to your favorite Rubbermaid container, you know the frustration of not being able to use it. Fortunately, replacement lids are available, making it easy to get back to storing your food efficiently. Here’s a guide to help you choose the right Rubbermaid replacement lids for your needs.

1. Identify Your Container Model

• Check Your Existing Containers: Look for any model numbers or labels on your Rubbermaid containers. This will help you find the corresponding replacement lids.
• Container Type: Rubbermaid offers a variety of container types (e.g., bowls, storage bins, food containers). Make sure to identify the specific type.

2. Lid Features

• Material: Most Rubbermaid lids are made from BPA-free plastic, which is safe for food storage. Choose lids that are durable and designed to withstand heat if you use them in microwaves.
• Seal Type: Consider whether you need an airtight seal for leftovers or a simpler lid for snacks. Some lids have locking mechanisms for added security.
• Compatibility: Ensure the lid you choose is compatible with your existing Rubbermaid containers.

3. Size Matters

• Dimensions: Measure the diameter or dimensions of your container openings to ensure you select the right size replacement lid.
• Volume: If you have multiple containers of different sizes, consider purchasing a variety pack or individual lids of varying sizes.

4. Color and Design

• Match or Contrast: While this may not affect performance, matching the color or design of your replacement lid with your current storage set can be aesthetically pleasing.
• Transparent vs. Opaque: Transparent lids allow you to see contents easily, while opaque lids may provide additional insulation for temperature control.

5. Brand Authenticity

• Official Retailers: Purchase from reputable sources, such as the official Rubbermaid website or authorized retailers, to ensure you’re getting genuine products.
• Replacement Kits: Look for kits specifically designed for your container type to ensure compatibility.

6. Price and Value

• Budget: Price can vary, so consider your budget. Replacement lids may be sold individually or as a set.
• Quality vs. Cost: Sometimes, spending a bit more on high-quality lids can save you money in the long term through durability.

7. Multipacks and Variety Packs

• If you frequently lose lids or have multiple containers, consider buying a multipack. This can often save you money and ensure you always have a lid on hand.

8. Check Reviews

• User Feedback: Look for online reviews and ratings on the lids you’re considering. High-quality products will typically have positive feedback regarding durability, fit, and usability.

9. Additional Features

• Microwave and Dishwasher Safe: Ensure the replacement lids can withstand both microwave heat and dishwasher cleaning for convenience.
• Stackable Design: Some lids allow for easier stacking of containers, which can save space in your kitchen.

10. Return Policy and Warranty

• Check Refund Options: Before making a purchase, see if the seller offers a return policy in case the lid does not fit as expected.
• Manufacturer Warranty: Some products may come with a warranty for additional peace of mind.

Conclusion

When searching for Rubbermaid replacement lids, consider compatibility with your existing containers, size, quality, and budget. With the right lid, you can extend the life of your Rubbermaid containers and keep your food fresh and secure. Happy shopping!