10 Best Baseball Cupcake Toppers for Parties in 2025

When it comes to celebrating the love for baseball, cupcakes adorned with baseball-themed toppers can take your party to the next level. The best baseball cupcake toppers not only add a touch of whimsy but also ensure the theme is consistent throughout your event. In this article, we will delve into the top 10 baseball cupcake toppers available on Amazon in 2025. Whether you’re throwing a birthday party for your little athlete or hosting a baseball-themed gathering, these cupcake toppers will surely delight your guests.

1. MLB Baseball Cupcake Toppers

MLB Baseball Cupcake Toppers – Party Decoration Supplies

If you want to bring the genuine feel of Major League Baseball to your gatherings, the MLB Baseball Cupcake Toppers are a fantastic choice. These officially licensed cupcake toppers come in a variety of designs featuring popular team logos, making them perfect for fans of any MLB team.

The set includes 24 high-quality toppers, made from food-safe materials. Each topper is approximately 2 inches tall, providing a standout feature on any cupcake. The vibrant colors and intricate designs will catch the eyes of both kids and adults.

**Pros:**

• Official MLB licensing ensures authenticity.
• Variety of team designs available.
• High-quality, food-safe materials.

**Cons:**

• May not be suitable for non-MLB fans.
• Limited to only MLB teams.

No products found.

2. Cute Baseball Cupcake Toppers by GIFTEXPRESS

Cute Baseball Cupcake Toppers by GIFTEXPRESS 24 pcs

The Cute Baseball Cupcake Toppers by GIFTEXPRESS offer a fun and playful twist on traditional designs. These toppers feature cartoonish baseball characters along with various baseball-related accessories, providing a delightful variety for your cupcakes.

Crafted from high-quality paper and food-safe materials, these toppers are not only cute but also durable. They come in a pack of 24, ensuring you have enough for your entire cupcake display. Their unique designs make them suitable for various occasions, from birthday parties to casual gatherings.

**Pros:**

• Adorable designs appeal to children.
• Made from durable, food-safe material.
• Perfect for various types of celebrations.

**Cons:**

• Not officially licensed, which may not appeal to some fans.
• Limited variety in terms of character options.

No products found.

3. Baseball Sugar Sprinkles for Cupcakes

Baseball Sugar Sprinkles for Cupcakes – Sport Themed Party Supplies

If you want to elevate your cupcake experience further, consider the Baseball Sugar Sprinkles for Cupcakes. These colorful edible sprinkles come in baseball shapes and add a delightful burst of sweetness to your treats. They are perfect for creating a baseball-themed dessert table and complement the cupcake toppers perfectly.

Available in a generous package, you’ll have plenty to sprinkle generously on your cupcakes and other desserts. Made from high-quality sugar and food coloring, these sprinkles are both tasty and visually appealing.

**Pros:**

• Adds flavor and decorations simultaneously.
• Great quantity for large parties.
• Versatile for other dessert decorations.

**Cons:**

• Can be overly sweet for some.
• Not specifically a topper, but a complementary item.

No products found.

4. Baseball Party Picks – 50 Count

Baseball Party Picks – 50 Count Cocktail Picks for Appetizers and Cupcakes

The Baseball Party Picks by Artisanal Goods are not your ordinary cupcake toppers. These mini picks feature a baseball design and can be used not just for cupcakes, but also for appetizers, snacks, or even fruit. With a sturdy plastic design, they’re great for outdoor parties and are built to last throughout the event.

Each pack contains 50 picks, making them ideal for large gatherings. Their eye-catching design will surely impress guests and enhance your baseball-themed decor.

**Pros:**

• Versatile use beyond cupcakes.
• Durable and sturdy plastic design.
• Large quantity per pack.

**Cons:**

• Design might not suit everyone’s aesthetic.
• Not reusable, making them less eco-friendly.

No products found.

5. Baseball Themed Cupcake Wrapper and Topper Set

Baseball Themed Cupcake Wrapper and Topper Set – 24 Count

This Baseball Themed Cupcake Wrapper and Topper Set offers a coordinated solution for your dessert display. The set includes 24 festive wrappers decorated with baseball motifs, complemented by matching toppers that feature baseballs and bats. This all-in-one solution will simplify your party prep without sacrificing style.

Made from durable food-safe materials, these wrappers not only look great but also hold up during the festivities. They fit standard-sized cupcakes and create an attractive display on any dessert table.

**Pros:**

• All-in-one wrapper and topper solution.
• Durable and food-safe materials.
• Uniform design for a cohesive theme.

**Cons:**

• Some assembly required.
• Wrappers may not fit larger cupcakes.

No products found.

6. Vintage Baseball Cupcake Toppers by Bakoel

Vintage Baseball Cupcake Toppers by Bakoel – 24 Pieces

If you have a soft spot for retro baseball designs, the Vintage Baseball Cupcake Toppers by Bakoel will appeal to you. This set combines nostalgic elements with modern cupcake decor. Each topper showcases classic baseball imagery, perfect for themed parties celebrating baseball history or vintage style.

The 24-piece set is crafted with care, using high-quality materials that ensure safety and durability. These toppers can work as conversation starters as they transport guests back to the golden days of baseball.

**Pros:**

• Unique vintage designs stand out.
• Ideal for themed parties celebrating baseball history.
• High-quality craftsmanship.

**Cons:**

• Limited appeal for younger fans.
• More expensive than standard designs.

No products found.

7. Personalized Baseball Cupcake Toppers

Personalized Baseball Cupcake Toppers – Custom Made for Your Occasion

For a truly unique touch, the Personalized Baseball Cupcake Toppers offer customization options that allow you to add a personal message or name, making them ideal for birthday celebrations, weddings, or team events. The custom design makes these toppers special and memorable, ensuring they stand out on your dessert table.

Crafted from food-safe materials, these toppers are both functional and decorative. The ability to add a personal touch makes them an excellent choice for those looking to create lasting memories.

**Pros:**

• Customization options make them unique.
• Great for special events.
• High-quality and food-safe materials.

**Cons:**

• Longer production time due to customization.
• More expensive than standard toppers.

No products found.

8. Baseball Cap Cupcake Toppers

Baseball Cap Cupcake Toppers – Set of 12

The Baseball Cap Cupcake Toppers add a fun twist with their cap-shaped designs. These miniature caps are perfect for baseball-themed events, offering a playful way to represent the sport. Made from high-quality materials, they fit right onto standard-sized cupcakes with ease.

The set of 12 ensures that you have enough for your dessert display, providing variety and excitement to each cupcake. They not only taste delightful but also serve as eye-catching decorations for your baseball gathering.

**Pros:**

• Fun and unique baseball cap design.
• Quality materials ensure safety.
• Ideal for baseball-themed parties.

**Cons:**

• Limited quantity may require ordering multiple sets.
• Not suitable for non-baseball events.

9. DIY Baseball Cupcake Toppers Kit

DIY Baseball Cupcake Toppers Kit – Create Your Own Designs

The DIY Baseball Cupcake Toppers Kit offers a unique experience, allowing you to unleash your creativity. This kit comes with materials to make your own cupcake toppers, including blank templates, markers, and bases for assembly. Perfect for kids’ birthday parties or craft-loving adults, this kit adds a hands-on element to your celebration.

The DIY option makes these toppers adaptable, allowing you to customize them for any occasion, from baseball parties to school events. Using food-safe materials ensures that these toppers are both safe and functional.

**Pros:**

• Encourages creativity and personalization.
• Fun activity for kids and adults alike.
• Great for various occasions.

**Cons:**

• Requires more time and effort to assemble.
• Not as polished as pre-made toppers.

No products found.

10. Baseball-themed Cupcake Picks – 50 Pack

Baseball-themed Cupcake Picks – 50 Pack with Assorted Designs

The Baseball-themed Cupcake Picks offer an assortment of designs in a single package, perfect for those who want variety at their event. Each pick features different baseball-related images, offering an exciting range for kids and adults alike. Made from high-quality, food-safe plastic, these picks are durable and easy to use.

This pack of 50 ensures that you have enough for a large gathering, making them ideal for parties, get-togethers, or even tailgating events. The creativity in the designs keeps the excitement alive, enticing guests to enjoy the cupcakes.

**Pros:**

• Variety in designs keeps things interesting.
• Large pack size for big events.
• Durable materials that can withstand a party atmosphere.

**Cons:**

• Some designs may not be suitable for all ages.
• Can appear cluttered with too many different designs.

No products found.

Now, whether you’re preparing for a birthday bash or a summer barbeque, the best baseball cupcake toppers we explored today will help make your event an unforgettable experience!

Buying Guide for Baseball Cupcake Toppers

Baseball-themed cupcake toppers can add a fun and festive touch to any baseball party, birthday celebration, or sports event. Whether you’re looking to celebrate a little league game or a World Series watch party, here’s a guide to help you choose the perfect cupcake toppers.

1. Types of Cupcake Toppers

• Edible Toppers: Made from sugar or rice paper that can be eaten alongside the cupcake. Ideal for those who want a cohesive edible theme.
• Non-Edible Toppers: Made of plastic, wood, or other materials. These can be reused and are great for decorative purposes.

2. Design Options

• Classic Baseball: Look for toppers that resemble actual baseballs, complete with stitching.
• Baseball Equipment: Consider toppers shaped like bats, gloves, helmets, or even balls in action.
• Team Logos: If you’re hosting a party honoring a specific team, look for toppers featuring team colors and logos.

3. Size Matters

• Ensure the size is appropriate for your cupcakes. Typically, toppers should stand about 2-4 inches tall to make an impact without overwhelming the cupcake.

4. Material Considerations

• Durability: Choose toppers made from sturdy materials if you plan to reuse them or if they will be outside.
• Food Safety: If opting for non-edible toppers, ensure they are food-safe and will not leach harmful substances.

5. Color and Theme Coordination

• Match the colors of your cupcake toppers with the party theme or team colors. Bright colors can enhance the festive feel.
• Consider pairing the toppers with coordinating cupcake liners and frosting colors.

6. Set Quantity

• Calculate how many cupcakes you’ll be serving and choose a set that fits your needs. Some toppers come in bulk packs, while others may be sold individually.

7. Easy to Use

• Look for toppers that are easy to place onto cupcakes without requiring any assembly. Pre-made designs save time and effort.

8. Budget

• Prices can vary based on material, design, and quantity. Set a budget and look for options that fit within it. Remember, quality is often worth the extra cost.

9. Personalization

• Some toppers can be customized with names, dates, or messages. This adds a special touch to the event. Check if the retailer offers personalization options.

10. Where to Buy

• Online Retailers: Websites like Amazon, Etsy, or party supply stores often have a wide range of choices.
• Local Party Stores: Visit brick-and-mortar stores for a more hands-on approach to selecting your toppers.
• Specialty Baking Stores: These may carry unique and high-quality options.

11. Reviews and Ratings

• Before making a purchase, consider reading customer reviews. This can provide insight into the quality and appearance of the toppers.

12. Shipping and Delivery

• If purchasing online, check shipping times, especially if your event is approaching. Opt for quicker shipping if needed, and review return policies in case the product doesn’t meet expectations.

Conclusion

Choosing the right baseball cupcake toppers can elevate your event, making it memorable and fun for guests of all ages. By considering the types, designs, materials, and where to purchase, you can find the perfect match for your baseball-themed celebration. Happy decorating!