Comparing Zooey Deschanel’s Exes with HGTV Star Fiance Jonathan Scott

Zooey Deschanel’s dating history typically involved musicians and Hollywood personalities. She revealed to Cosmopolitan that she initially ventured into dating with actor and musician Jason Schwartzman when she was 19. They eventually broke up but rekindled their relationship later, only to split again after two years.

In 2008, Deschanel’s manager introduced her to Ben Gibbard, Death Cab for Cutie’s frontman. They got married in 2009 but separated in 2011. Later, Deschanel married producer Jacob Pechenik in 2015 and had two children together before divorcing in 2020. Her first industry romance was with “Legally Blonde” actor Matthew Davis in 2000, a private relationship that hinted at her penchant for celebrity partners.

Despite her history with fellow celebs, Deschanel told Cosmopolitan UK that profession wasn’t a criterion for her ideal man. Instead, she valued intelligence and humor. That comes as no surprise since she found her perfect match in someone who deviated from her past dating pattern: HGTV’s Jonathan Scott.

Unlike Deschanel’s previous partners, Jonathan Scott doesn’t resemble them physically or professionally. Most of Deschanel’s exes sported a cool hipster look that matched her manic pixie dream girl vibe. Jonathan brings a rugged charm that contrasts and complements her appeal.

However, Jonathan does share one crucial trait with Deschanel’s former lovers: a creative streak. In 2015, he and his twin brother Drew formed the musical duo The Scott Brothers. They released several singles like “Let The Night Shine” and “Hold On,” showcasing their musical talents. Growing up with music as a constant part of their family life, the Scott brothers felt right at home in the industry.

Jonathan also dabbled in playing the piano and had mastered the bagpipes by 2017, as he shared in an interview with Us Weekly.

Reflecting on their relationship in 2023, Jonathan Scott mentioned to People that people were puzzled by his and Zooey Deschanel’s pairing when they first went public on Instagram. Deschanel countered this confusion, asserting their compatibility and noting that their personalities meshed well despite coming from different backgrounds.

The couple’s first date took place at an escape room, and they confessed their love at an exclusive magician club where Jonathan was a member. Jonathan acknowledged in a 2020 People interview that their relationship might not make sense on paper, but their lives shared many similarities, from equestrian backgrounds to education.

Even after they started dating, insiders noted their shared sense of humor and love for music, which brought them closer. It’s no surprise that Jonathan was immediately taken with Deschanel, and while some may still question their relationship, their loved ones understand it well. Drew Scott even highlighted the special nature of their bond.