‘Good Bones’ Fans Call for Cancellation Amid New Season Backlash

When HGTV announced that Good Bones would be returning, many fans were thrilled. However, those aware of the behind-the-scenes drama were puzzled about its comeback. The show’s return has left fans divided, with some calling for its end.

Here’s what transpired in the new season of Good Bones and why fans are disillusioned with the new format.

As Good Bones: New Beginnings premiered, it brought both excitement and confusion. Excitement, because the original series was beloved by many. Confusion, because the show’s stars, Mina Starsiak Hawk and Karen Laine, are reportedly estranged.

This new season features the mother-daughter duo working on separate projects, even in different states, without any communication between them. The unique chemistry that once made the show popular was absent, leaving fans questioning its revival.

Although many viewers were pleased to see Karen back on TV, others believe HGTV should consider ending the show entirely.

• “Good Bones. We waited for this premiere. The formula is gone.”
• “The chemistry of the series is gone. I’m not sure what the hell the first episode was. We couldn’t finish it.”
• “I don’t even understand the point of continuing this show. At all.”

Some fans also criticized and mocked Mina’s husband Steve, who appeared alongside her in the episodes. Despite Karen’s return, many felt it wasn’t enough to save the show.

When Good Bones first started, it followed Karen and Mina as they expanded their company, Two Chicks and a Hammer, Inc., on HGTV. Their dynamic and banter won over audiences as they renovated homes in Indianapolis.

However, the new chapter titled Good Bones: New Beginnings couldn’t capture the same essence. Mina and Karen, being estranged for years, meant they were separately working on different projects. Mina worked on renovating an Indiana lake home, while Karen focused on her “retirement nest egg” in North Carolina.

Last year, Mina disclosed that she hadn’t spoken to her mother for a considerable time. She cited personal reasons, making it clear that the fans’ fondness for Good Bones stemmed from the duo’s interaction, which is now missing.

So, what do you think of Good Bones: New Beginnings? Is the show worth continuing with the new format of mother and daughter working separately? Or should it come to an end? Share your thoughts in the comments below.