Keith Urban: Why Carrie Underwood Stands Out Among Other Judges

Former American Idol judge Keith Urban says that the new judge, Carrie Underwood, brings a unique perspective that sets her apart from the current panel. Carrie, who won Season 4 in 2005, has stepped in to fill Katy Perry’s spot after Perry chose to leave at the end of last season to focus on her music career.

Carrie was part of the first generation of American Idol stars, alongside big names like Kelly Clarkson and Jordin Sparks. Back then, the judging panel included Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, and Randy Jackson. Over time, the judges evolved, with Keith Urban, Jennifer Lopez, and Harry Connick Jr. taking seats. The show later switched networks, bringing in Katy Perry, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie.

Now, with Carrie joining Luke and Lionel, Keith Urban believes she offers something special, particularly because she has been through the same rigorous competition. Speaking to American Songwriter, Keith emphasized the advantages of her firsthand experience and deemed her “perfect” for the role:

“She knows exactly what everybody on the other side of the desk is going through. Lionel doesn’t. Luke doesn’t. She’s going to bring something really extraordinary to that seat.”

Lionel Richie shares Keith’s enthusiasm, noting how Carrie’s background offers an unparalleled connection with the contestants:

“Now we don’t have to explain anymore, ‘We know how you feel.’ As artists, we know how you feel, but we’ve never been in that oval that says, ‘American Idol.’ She’s been there, done that.”

Jordin Sparks also expressed interest in becoming a judge to provide that empathetic connection, similar to Carrie. Jordin, who won Season 6, was eager to step up when Katy Perry announced her departure.

Fans of Carrie Underwood and American Idol were thrilled by the announcement. Social media was abuzz with comments lauding the choice:

• Full circle!!! So proud of your success and this new journey. Truly the GOAT of Idol
• Perfect choice for a judge on idol ❤️❤️
• Awesome! What a journey you have had! Talk about a full circle!❤️🙌
• Lol. 20 years ago I watched you sing on that first episode and told my wife, “She’s going to win.” Glad I picked the winner. Lol

The show’s viewers are eagerly waiting to see how Carrie will approach her new role as a judge. Her unique experience as a past contestant is expected to bring a fresh and insightful perspective to her critiques and advice.

How do you feel about Carrie joining American Idol as a judge? Do you agree with Keith and Lionel that her background makes her the perfect fit? Share your thoughts in the comments below.