Ranking Every Murderer in ‘Only Murders in the Building,’ Including S3 Twist

Only Murders in the Building is back, and surprise, there are even more murders! Every season of the new Hulu show focuses on three avid podcasters trying to solve a classic whodunnit.

The show stars Steve Martin as Charles-Haden Savage, Martin Short as Oliver Putnam, and Selena Gomez as Mabel Mora. The three sleuths live in the exclusive Acornia in New York’s Upper West Side and share a love of true crime. After the success of finding out who killed their neighbor, it seems like the success of their podcast (also titled Only Murders in the Building) manifests a new killer every season. And for season 4, there might be someone in the Only Murders gang who becomes a target.

Below, we ranked each guilty killer from each Only Murders in the Building season finale. From poisoning to gunshots, and pushing people down elevators, see which killers were cunning and those who succumbed to their own wrongdoing.