American Pie Cast: Meet Their Husbands, Wives, and Kids

Since the classic comedy American Pie came out 25 years ago on July 9, 1999, many of the film’s former teen stars have gone on to have families of their own—though perhaps none as perfectly hilarious and cringe as Eugene Levy and Jason Biggs’ Noah and Jim Levenstein.

“Wherever I travel, people want to talk to me about it,” Biggs recently told PEOPLE. “There’s now another one or two generations of people that have seen the movie, identified with the movie, liked the movie. It’s been a really, really special thing for me. It’s very cool to be here 25 years later and still talking about it.”

As Biggs continues raising his two sons with wife and author Jenny Mollen and several of his castmates have started families of their own, see the stars of American Pie alongside their real-life partners and children.

Actors Alyson Hannigan (American Pie‘s Michelle) and Alexis Denisof had a very Hollywood meet-cute on the set of Buffy the Vampire Slayer in the late ’90s. Hannigan, now 50, starred on the series as the witch Willow, and Denisof, now 58, played the watcher Westley Wyndam-Price. Hannigan once said it was “flirtation at first sight.”

The stars wed in 2003, and have since welcomed two daughters, Satyana Marie and Keeva Jane. They’ve also shared the screen on other pop culture favorites, including her series How I Met Your Mother.

Eugene Levy and producer Deborah Divine have been together since the 1970s, and have expanded their show business family with son Dan, daughter Sarah and grandson James.

When Levy, now 77, won the outstanding lead actor in a comedy series Emmy Award for Schitt’s Creek in 2020, his first thank-you was to his wife, “for all the love, support and sage counsel over the years. I wouldn’t be up here without you, Deb,” he continued. “I love you.”

Shannon Elizabeth (who played Nadia) and brand strategist Simon Borchert share not only a passion for each other, but for the environment. Though they don’t often speak publicly about their relationship, the pair work together through her namesake foundation to protect rhinos and strengthen conservation efforts through “engaging with legislators,” according to an episode of The Do One Better podcast. Elizabeth, 50, and Borchert have also hosted a podcast together, The Art of Conservation.

John Cho (‘MILF Guy’), now 52, and fellow actor Kerri Higuchi married in 2006, during her stint on Grey’s Anatomy. Together, the private couple shares two children, one boy and one girl, according to Us Weekly.

In 2019, Tara Reid (who played Vicky) went Instagram official with boyfriend and music producer Nathan Montpetit-Howar while they were on vacation in Mexico. In the years since, Reid, now 48, and Montpetit-Howar have remained prominent on each other’s feeds and made a handful of public appearances together.

Source: PEOPLE, Us Weekly, The Do One Better podcast